New Delhi – On Monday the Supreme Court declined to issue any immediate order against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, despite petitions that question his conduct and the decision‑making process of the Election Commission of India (ECI). The court, however, has asked the Commission to furnish a written response and relevant documents before it decides the next steps.
Court Wants the ECI’s Version First
The bench, led by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and joined by Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohan, issued a notice to the Election Commission in response to petitions filed by Rakesh Kumar Singh and advocate Shailendra Mani Tripathi. The judges made clear that they will evaluate the allegations only after receiving the Commission’s reply and supporting records. At this stage, no suspension, removal, or restriction of the Chief Election Commissioner’s duties has been ordered.
Petitioners’ Core Allegations
The filings contend that several decisions, which under the law must be taken collectively by the three Election Commissioners, were allegedly made unilaterally by the CEC. Rakesh Kumar Singh seeks an interim order that bars Gyanesh Kumar from acting as Chief Election Commissioner until the case concludes, and that the Commission’s functioning during that period reflect the unanimous view of the other two commissioners.
In a separate petition, Shailendra Mani Tripathi asks for criminal proceedings against the CEC and other officials, alleging violations of their statutory duties.
Dispute Over Collective Decision‑Making
The petitioners invoke the 2023 amendment to the Election Commission Act, arguing that internal disagreements should be resolved through the prescribed decision‑making mechanism, including the majority principle where appropriate. They claim that certain powers, which belong to the Commission as a whole, were exercised by the CEC alone, and they raise concerns about modifications to election‑related software.
The Election Commission maintains that all its orders are legally sound and that differing opinions among members are a normal part of any deliberative body.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) Under Scrutiny
The petitions also bring the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls into focus. Citing a media report, the petitioners allege that the two other Election Commissioners repeatedly objected to specific SIR decisions over the past ten months.
Controversy Over Form‑6 Changes
Form‑6, the voter‑registration form, is another flashpoint. The petitioners assert that the Election Commission introduced changes via election software—such as new requirements about ancestors’ details and links to prior SIR exercises—without following the mandated legal procedure.
Regional Cases: Goa and West Bengal
- Goa: Petitioners claim that, although instructions were issued to restore 97 eligible voters’ names, the software lacked a mechanism to re‑add them.
- West Bengal: The petitions reference more than 1.61 million appeals related to the state’s electoral‑roll process.
Next Steps After the EC’s Reply
The Supreme Court has not treated the allegations as established facts at this juncture. Instead, it awaits the Election Commission’s detailed response and accompanying records before deciding whether any further judicial intervention is warranted. The Commission’s submission will be pivotal in determining whether the contested decisions complied with statutory requirements and the collective decision‑making framework prescribed for the body.



